The Backstory – Why Poor People Make Bad Choices – Fake Poverty Essays Now Really?
I am having to reach way back into my Brooklyn roots to respond to yet another example of how privilege and the system continue to maintain the status quo while those truly in need stay getting screwed.
I like many others discovered Linda Tirado’s essay on Huffington Post (rethinking keeping the RSS feed for this site). The article as penned was a view from inside the life of someone who purportedly was working poor and living in poverty.
The story was complete with visual references and the angle as presented was why people in poverty make bad choices. Clearly, it resonated with a lot of people as the article went completely viral and it’s hard to find a Facebook timeline that hasn’t seen at least one version of this article. AS usually happens with stories like this which paint a picture of hopelessness and a brave soul struggling to live amongst the figurative rocks, many people turned around after reading this article and donated to Ms. Tirado with I am sure the best of intentions. To date Ms. Tirado has raised over $60K from a gofundme.com page she set up after writing the piece.
Problem is the story as written was a discussion of Ms. Tirado’s bad choices and life lived in poverty when in fact, her life has been everything BUT poverty-stricken.
I need Shirley Ceasar to come sing “hold my mule” right now….
Ms. Tirado grew up in a UPPER middle class family and attended boarding school. She currently lives in a house that her parents generously funded and footed the bill for. She Is married to a Marine and has allegedly met President Obama once in person. She lists as occupation, freelance writer and political consultant going back to 2010. Oh and she attended boarding school growing up because of course that was what all middle class families did – send their kids to boarding school…..
“Hold my mule…”
If this is not the epitome of white privilege and an example of the systemic economic disparity that exists in this country I will give completely up.
People were feeling some kind of way because they felt Miley Cyrus appropriated tweaking and is making bank of “black culture”? It’s ok though for this paragon of virtue to write about poverty and profit from it. How do these things get decided? Somebody let me know when the next “Important topic for black folks to get mad about” meeting is going to be held so I can be sure and attend.
In a country where an overwhelming amount of the populace has been brainwashed to believe that the majority of brown folks are collecting a welfare check and running off to buy Cadillac’s, diamonds and pearls this story sticks so deeply in my craw that I am choking on the cuss words as I type this.
Let me just clear up things RIGHT up front… Those of you who are averse to profanity can click off now because there will be cussing
.I can speak to poverty I HAVE lived it, I have been working poor most of my life and I grew up in a working class family who did NOT have the funds to send me to boarding school even though academically I might have benefitted from it – instead attending a public school for Gifted and talented children.
Unlike Ms. Tirado I my parent (my father died when I was 14), cannot afford to BUY me a house. I was happy enough for her when she managed after working for over 50 years to retire in to the house of HER dreams. She is now living on her retirement and pension and taking care of HER own mother who also managed to buy a house of her own without RICH parents to pay anything towards it. In fact, she was sending money TO HER PARENTS while saving up for the house she ultimately bought.
AS to the choices that she lied about in her article, I have had hard choices, I have had to live on potato chips for months because there wasn’t enough money to buy much anything else. Choosing between paying a bill and eating is a regular occurrence. There are way too many situations where the choices are between bad and worse and if you don’t develop a way to put all that into perspective, you can add mental health issues and hypertension to the list of negatives that go along with the so-called bad choices.
AS far as the roaches’ story goes, not everyone who is poor has roaches….stereotypical bullshit that poor people are dirty and live in hovels. You would be surprised at how some people living in McMansions are REALLY living and what goes on behind closed doors. But stereotyping is easier and more fun so I see why she went there with that one.
To the millions of Americans of all ethnicities like myself who have not had insurance or seen a doctor in years I say, forgive her ignorance. In writing about her long standing inability to get dental care even when she had resources available to her to obtain care but (made bad choices), it minimalized the struggle that we all as uninsured go through in this country. Each day hoping the sniffle doesn’t turn into a full-fledged cold or that the stomach ache goes away and praying to never have to wind up in the emergency room. Or just walking around in pain hoping it goes away at some point.
It wasn’t bad enough that this out of touch, class-unconscious pseudo-progressive decided to write a pack of lies and pass it on as her own experience, she actually decided to profit from it assisted by those bleeding heart folks who read her story – published on one of the leading news blog sites and got out their credit cards, checkbooks etc. and sent her money to ease her non-existent poverty.
The system then did what it was supposed to. A writer with the level of exposure reserved for celebrities and other public figures, wrote a call to action and people acted and sent her money for a story that wasn’t really hers to begin with. For this I reserve a big fuck you to Ms. Tirado for feeling “entitled” to those donations even though it wasn’t actually Her OWN experiences she was writing about.
I am struggling to make ends meet with NO HUSBAND and NO children. I am gone 12 hours a day to work in an at will work state which means I can lose my job at any minute for no reason. I am at the same TIME attending college where I actually STOPPED looking at the student loan balances because it was making me sick to see how much those were racking up. Fuck you because I can’t even get money to help buy my textbooks or offset some of those student loans which I will probably be paying back for the rest of my life. But YOU write a fictitious story about your experiences with poverty and get $60k that you plan on taking a trip to Vegas with? Really?
I have never been to Vegas, I can’t remember the last time I went on anything remotely resembling a vacation – (2008 – spent weekend in Washington D.C.). Hell I have never been to Disneyland but this “well it’s not my fault that people took what I said out of context” trick is laughing all the way to the bank and collecting paper
See this is not our system. Black people did not create the current economic system that exists in this country. We did not create a system by which a white woman can write a screed on poverty that she never personally experienced and get published on the leading news blog site on the net.
There are far too many talented sistas out here who can make Shakespeare sound like Mother Goose for that. None of them are getting the same opportunities for exposure. Heck those who are living in some form of poverty may not even have access to a pc to write in the first place. Some like me do not have wealthy family and friends to siphon money off of to go purchase a home or any other big ticket items.
But the need was felt by this writer to compose this piece that speaks from the perspective of someone who has lived struggle, when in fact that is not the case and is profiting from it on top of it.
If white America, and or the so-called general public wish to know about the bad choices made by those in poverty just ask. There are PLENTY of us out here that would be more than willing to tell you from our OWN PERSONAL EXPERIENCE what its like living not even pay check to paycheck; not knowing where your next dollar is going to come from or what you will have to DO to get money to pay that bill, rent, etc.
Note: the selection of the video clip to accompany this piece was very deliberate and intentional. A historical representation of one of the things that got many through their struggles financial and otherwise. The Fisk Jubilee singers have a rich history that you can read more about by visiting their site. Finding that bright spot in the midst of the darkness. A Skill-set that brown folks are way too experienced in.